Self-Hosted vs Hosted Website Monitoring: How to Choose
Self-hosted tools like changedetection.io, urlwatch and Huginn are free software you run yourself. Hosted tools run for you. A one-minute rule, what each costs, and a goal table.
By AyeWatch Team4 min read
Short answer: Self-host website monitoring if you already run a server, want your data and page list on your own machine, and are happy to maintain it. Use a hosted service if you want alerts working in minutes with no server to patch. Self-hosted software is free to download, but you pay in hosting and time.
The one-minute decision rule
Answer three questions. Do you already run a server or a home machine that stays on? Do your page list, credentials or results have to stay on hardware you control? Do you enjoy editing config files?
Three yes answers: self-host. Fewer than two: use a hosted tool. Exactly two: try a hosted tool for a week first. That costs a trial, not a weekend.
The three self-hosted tools
- changedetection.io. Open source, with CSS and XPath rules and trigger or ignore text. Its site lists over 85 notification types and optional AI summaries if you bring your own API key. The same site sells a hosted subscription, covered below, that includes a real Chrome browser for JavaScript sites.
- urlwatch. A command-line tool. You write jobs in a YAML file, add filters such as css and xpath, and configure reporters such as email, Slack, Discord and Telegram. A change notification includes the URL and a unified diff.
- Huginn. A system of agents for automations, run with Docker and licensed under MIT. See the Huginn alternative guide.
What you take on when you self-host
- A machine that stays on. Huginn also needs a MySQL or PostgreSQL database.
- The schedule. urlwatch has no clock of its own: per its docs, the interval is how often you run it, so you add it to cron or Windows Task Scheduler.
- JavaScript pages. urlwatch's plain url jobs fetch only what the server returns, and a separate headless-browser job type handles pages that need JavaScript.
- Silence. If the server stops, the alerts stop, and nothing tells you unless a second monitor checks the first.
- Repairs. When a page layout changes, you edit the job.
What a hosted monitor takes off your plate
A hosted monitor runs on the vendor's servers, so there is no machine to keep up and nothing to patch. AyeWatch adds a plain-English rule and a summary of each change, and sends push alerts to your phone with no setup beyond the URL. The trade is dependence. If the vendor changes a plan, raises a price or shuts down, you move; with self-hosted software you can keep running the version you have.
Sample rule: "Alert me when the Calder County planning portal lists a new application on Mill Road or changes a hearing date."
Sample alert (illustrative): Calder County listed a new application on Mill Road. A 14-unit housing proposal was added to the portal, with a hearing set for Jan 14. The earlier Mill Road hearing date is unchanged.
When AyeWatch is the wrong tool
- Your data must stay on your hardware. AyeWatch is hosted, so use a self-hosted tool when policy requires otherwise.
- Internal pages. AyeWatch reads public pages and cannot sign in or reach a private network. A self-hosted tool on your network can.
- The exact diff on every run. urlwatch reports a unified diff. AyeWatch reports a summary in words.
- Your own schedule. A self-hosted tool runs as often as you set it. AyeWatch checks hourly on Pro and faster in ASAP mode on Pro+, and does not do sub-minute checks.
- Many notification channels. changedetection.io lists over 85 types. AyeWatch sends push and the in-app feed, plus email, Slack and webhooks on paid plans.
What each route costs
The software for changedetection.io, urlwatch and Huginn is free, but the machine and your time are not. As of November 2026, changedetection.io's own hosted plan is $8.99/mo for up to 5,000 URLs, with a real Chrome browser included. AyeWatch Pro is $9/mo with 50 topics and hourly checks; Pro+ is $19/mo with 200 topics and ASAP mode. Every plan starts with a 7-day free trial. See AyeWatch vs changedetection.io for the head-to-head.
| Your goal | Use this |
|---|---|
| Alerts on my phone today, with no setup | Hosted (AyeWatch) |
| Page list and results stay on my own hardware | Self-hosted (changedetection.io or urlwatch) |
| Monitor an internal or intranet page | Self-hosted, on your network |
| A plain-English rule and a short summary | Hosted (AyeWatch) |
| The exact text diff in my terminal or inbox | urlwatch or changedetection.io |
| Chains of steps: read, filter, reformat, post | Huginn |
| Self-hosted software without running the server | changedetection.io's hosted subscription |
| Is my own site up? | Uptime Kuma (self-hosted) or a hosted uptime monitor |
Start a monitor in under a minute
Describe a topic or paste a URL. Cancel before the trial ends and you pay nothing.
Try it free for 7 daysThe bottom line
Answer the three questions in the decision rule. If you land on hosted, start one AyeWatch monitor on a page you check by hand today. If you land on self-hosted, run changedetection.io or urlwatch on one page first and add the rest after a quiet week.
FAQ
What is the best self-hosted website monitoring tool?
For page changes, changedetection.io and urlwatch. For uptime, Uptime Kuma. For multi-step automations, Huginn.
Is self-hosted monitoring cheaper than hosted?
The software is free, but you pay for the machine and your time. changedetection.io's own hosted plan is $8.99/mo for up to 5,000 URLs as of November 2026, and AyeWatch Pro is $9/mo for 50 topics.
Does urlwatch run by itself?
No. Per its docs, how often it checks is how often you run it, so you add it to cron or Windows Task Scheduler.
Can a hosted tool monitor an internal page?
No. AyeWatch reads public pages and cannot sign in or reach a private network.
Can I use both self-hosted and hosted tools?
Yes. Use a self-hosted tool for internal pages and a hosted one for public pages. The two jobs do not overlap.
