Hacker news alerts: watch the thread, not the front page
A refresh shows you what won. A watch on one thread, one name or one Show HN post shows you what needs an answer.
3 min read
Hacker news alerts are watches set on a name, a thread or a category rather than on the site as a whole. The front page is ranked for everyone, and an alert is ranked for you: it should arrive with the claim, the link and enough context to decide whether to answer.
Four pages, not one site
Hacker News is a public page at news.ycombinator.com, with a ranked list of stories at the top and a header that splits into new, past, comments, ask, show and jobs. Every story, comment and job is an item with its own id, and the comments sit under the story as a tree. That means a watch on HN can point at four different things.
| Surface | What moves there | What a watch on it is for |
|---|---|---|
| Front page | Rank, score and the order of stories | Knowing what the crowd is reading, which is the noisiest signal |
| Newest | Every submission as it arrives, before votes decide anything | Catching a launch in its first minutes |
| One item page | Its comments, score and text | The thread about you, a competitor or a dependency |
| A user's submissions | Everything one account posts | A rival's launches, or your own posts |
The front page is a bad default
A watch on the homepage fires all day and says nothing about you, and a topic as broad as Python or AI publishes far more than one person can answer. The useful rule names a product, a misspelling, a competitor, a repository you maintain, a Show HN post in your category or a CVE in something you ship.
Write the rule as a sentence you could hand to a colleague: tell me when a thread names the product and a comment reports a bug, a price change or a clone. Add what to skip, such as job posts, meetup announcements and hiring threads. A rule with an exclusion is easier to keep than a rule you keep muting.
What an alert has to contain
The alert is not the reading. It is the reason to read one page. A short summary that names the claim, the story title and the comment, plus a link to the item, lets you decide from a phone whether the thread needs an answer in the first hour. An alert that only says the page changed hands the work back to you, and you are back to refreshing.
Set it up in AyeWatch
AyeWatch watches public pages, topics and public social accounts, and sends a summary when something that matters changes. Point it at the item page for a thread you expect, or describe the topic and let it watch the site for the name. It has no native Hacker News integration and no karma dashboard. It reads the public page and reports what changed.
Push and the feed come with every plan. Email, Slack, Discord, webhooks and the API are on paid plans, which start at $9 a month and are billed in monitoring credits, with a 7-day trial on the web. For a front page thread that needs a founder reply, push is the one that matters.
When the tab is still the right tool
If you read Hacker News for the pleasure of it, keep the tab. A monitor is for the thread you would otherwise find in a customer email three days late. Use it for the handful of names that would change a roadmap, and leave the front page to the front page.
FAQ
Are hacker news alerts free?
The site is free to read and its API is public, so a script can poll it. AyeWatch is the paid option: a 7-day trial, then plans from $9 a month.
Can I watch one thread instead of the whole site?
Yes. Every story has an item page and the comments load on it, so that page is the thing to watch. A watch on the homepage will not tell you which thread moved.
Will an alert tell me why a story is popular?
No. It reports that a page changed. The score, the comments and the reason are on the page.
FAQ
Are hacker news alerts free?
The site is free to read and its API is public, so a script can poll it. AyeWatch is the paid option: a 7-day trial, then plans from $9 a month.
Can I watch one thread instead of the whole site?
Yes. Every story has an item page and the comments load on it, so that page is the thing to watch. A watch on the homepage will not tell you which thread moved.
Will an alert tell me why a story is popular?
No. It reports that a page changed. The score, the comments and the reason are on the page.
Originally published on claudegpt.si